Shoofly Pie Marshmallows


Tastes just like the famous Lancaster County treat!



Shoofly Pie Marshmallows. That’s right. Brown sugar, molasses, and crumbs. ‘Nuff said. With these three melded together in a soft and squishy marshmallow, how could you possibly go wrong?

Never heard of Shoofly Pie? It’s a staple here in the Lancaster County area. An ooey gooey molasses layer is topped with thick crumbs to make this pie a treat any time of day, especially when served with milk.

We use the same molasses in these mallows that bakers all over the area use for their pies. It has a rich flavor unsurpassed by others.

We finish these Shoofly Pie Mallows by tossing them in gluten-free crumbs for an authentic shoofly pie experience.

Suggested uses: Perfect as a treat by themselves or on a dessert board with other goodies.

Each marshmallow is approximately 1.25″ x 1.25″. The 12-count package weighs 6 oz./170g. The 6-count package weighs 3 oz./85g.

Gluten free!

Ingredients: light brown cane sugar, filtered water, molasses, non-GMO corn syrup, crumbs (teff flour, light brown cane sugar, tapioca starch, butter [cream(milk), natural flavoring], sea salt), gelatin, vanilla (vanilla bean extractives in water, alcohol), sea salt. Less than 0.5 percent butter [cream(milk), natural flavoring].

Contains: milk

Produced in a facility that also uses soy, wheat, nut, and peanut products.

Marshmallows are best consumed within 3-4 weeks of receiving when they are at their freshest. Store in an airtight container after opening or freeze to extend freshness.


There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “Shoofly Pie Marshmallows”

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You may also like…